Cart

New York PizzaRatings & ReviewsRestaurant Stories

Rating 20 Pizza Slice Shops in New York City

By November 3, 2019November 4th, 2019No Comments
We reached out to @Jessanotherslice, one of our contributors, to share some insights into her adventures in eating and rating pizza in New York City! See below for the results!
I have come up with 20 of my favorite slice shops in New York City.
Then, I realized doing a ranking of all 20 was too difficult, so I did a further breakdown and organized them by flavor (i.e. Plain, Pepperoni, Vodka, Burrata, & Buffalo Chicken Ranch). Each review consists of the rating for Yelp, Google Maps and lists the neighborhood as well as nearby subways. Enjoy!
Contributor Bio | Jessica Einstein

Plain Pizza Category

Di Fara

  • Yelp: 4/5🌟
  • Google Maps: 4.2/5🌟
  • Neighborhood: Midwood, Brooklyn
  • Nearby Subways: B/Q

Bleecker Street Pizza

  • Yelp: 4.5/5🌟
  • Google Maps: 4.4/5🌟
  • Neighborhood: West Village, Bleecker St and 7th Ave South
  • Nearby Subways: 1/B/D/F/M/A/C/E

Fiore’s Pizza

  • Yelp: 4/5 🌟
  • Google Maps: 4.1/5 🌟
  • Neighborhood: West Village, Bleecker St & Sullivan St
  • Nearby Subways: B/D/F/M/A/C/E

Pugsley Pizza

  • Yelp: 4.5/5 🌟
  • Google Maps:Β  4.6/5 🌟
  • Neighborhood: Little Italy, Bronx
  • Nearby Transit: B/D & Metronorth routes: Harlem/New Canaan/New Haven

Joe’s Pizza

  • Yelp: 4/5 🌟
  • Google: 4.5/5 🌟
  • Neighborhood: West Village, Carmine St & Bleecker St
  • Nearby Subways: A/C/E/B/D/F/M

The Original Little Italy

  • Yelp: 3.5/5 🌟
  • Google: 4.4/5 🌟
  • Neighborhood: Midtown East, 43rd St & 5th Ave
  • Nearby Subways: 4/5/6/7/S/B/D/F/M

Best Pizza

  • Yelp: 3.5/5🌟
  • Google Maps: 4.5/5🌟
  • Neighborhood: Williamsburg, Havemeyer St and N 7th St
  • Nearby Subways: L/G

Williamsburg Pizza

  • Yelp: 4/5🌟
  • Google Maps: 4.3/5🌟
  • Neighborhood: Lower East Side, Allen St and Broome St
  • Nearby Subways: F/M/J/Z

Sal and Carmine’s

  • Yelp: 3.5/5 🌟
  • Google Maps: 4.4/5 🌟
  • Neighborhood: Upper West Side, Broadway & 102nd st
  • Nearby Subways: 1

Pepperoni Pizza Category

Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop (the hellboy slice)

  • Yelp: 4/5🌟
  • Google Maps: 4.4/5🌟
  • Neighborhood: Greenpoint, BK; Franklin St & Noble St
  • Nearby Subways: G

Mama’s Too

  • Yelp: 3.5/5 🌟
  • Google Maps: 4.3/5 🌟
  • Neighborhood: Upper West Side, Broadway & 106th St
  • Nearby Subways: 1

Vodka Pizza Category

Prince St Pizza

  • Yelp: 4.5/5🌟
  • Google Maps: 4.6/5🌟
  • Neighborhood: SoHo, Prince St & Mott St
  • Nearby Subways: B/D/F/M/J/Z/R/W/6

Grand Avenue Pizza (penne vodka slice)

  • Yelp: 3.5/5🌟
  • Google Maps: 4.3/5 🌟
  • Neighborhood: Astoria, 30th Ave & 35th St
  • Nearby Subways: N/W

Artichoke Basille’s Pizza

  • Yelp: 4/5 🌟
  • Google: 4.3/5 🌟
  • Neighborhood: East Village, E 14th St & 2nd Ave
  • Nearby Subway: L

Sofia Pizza Shoppe

  • Yelp: 4.5/5 🌟
  • Google Maps: 4.6/5 🌟
  • Neighborhood: Midtown East
  • Nearby Subways: E/M/6

Burrata Pizza Category

NY Pizza Suprema

  • Yelp: 4/5🌟
  • Google Maps: 4.6/5🌟
  • Neighborhood: Midtown West, 32nd St & 8th Ave
  • Nearby Subways: A/C/E/1/2/3

L’Industrie Pizza

  • Yelp: 5/5🌟
  • Google Maps: 4.7/5🌟
  • Neighborhood: Williamsburg, Havemeyer St & S 2nd St
  • Nearby Subways: J/Z/M

Buffalo Chicken Ranch Pizza Category

Champion Pizza

  • Yelp: 4/5 🌟
  • Google: 4.4/5 🌟
  • Neighborhood: Union Square, 14th St & 5th Ave
  • Nearby Subways: N/Q/R/W/F/M/PATH/4/5/6

Previti Pizza

  • Yelp: 4/5 🌟
  • Google Maps: 4.4/5 🌟
  • Neighborhood: Midtown East, 41st St & Lexington Ave
  • Nearby Subways: 4/5/6/7/S

Doughboys

  • Yelp: 3.5/5 🌟
  • Google Maps: 3.9/5 🌟
  • Neighborhood: Kips Bay, 31st & 3rd
  • Nearby Subways: 6

Article by Jessica Einstein

Yelp Elite & Slice Influencer | New York City Pizza β€˜Grammer

Hi Guys! I’m Jess and pizza was my first word. Just kidding, but I have been eating it for as long as I can remember. I’m lucky to live in the best city in the world with phenomenal pizza. My goal is to share photos and information about the best pizzas and create a more organized hashtag system to locate pizza by neighborhood.

Contributor Bio | Jessica Einstein